The second side of the market
The cold start problem is stated so often that it has stopped being heard. Everybody knows a marketplace needs both sides. Almost every marketplace launches assuming the second side will show up because the first one did.
The asymmetry nobody plans for
The two sides are rarely equally hard. One of them usually has somewhere else to go and no particular reason to try you; the other has an unmet need and will tolerate a half-built product. Which is which is the single most useful thing to work out before building anything, and it is knowable by asking fifteen people rather than by launching.
The side with options is the side you have to buy, seed, subsidise or personally recruit. The side with the need is the side that will forgive you.
Work out which side is scarce, then stop treating the launch as a product problem and start treating it as a supply problem.
Three ways to be the second side yourself
- Quote it. In anything resembling a book or an exchange, take the other side at a published rule until natural flow arrives. This costs money and should be budgeted as a launch cost, not discovered as a loss.
- Fill it by hand. Do the thing the marketplace will eventually automate, manually, for the first cohort. It does not scale, which is fine, because the question being answered is whether anybody wants it at all.
- Narrow it until it is dense. A marketplace for one city, one category and one week is a marketplace that can actually be filled. One for everything everywhere is permanently empty in every particular corner of it.
The honest version of "we will seed it"
Seeding is respectable and common. What is not respectable is seeding without saying so — inventory that does not exist, counterparties who are the operator, activity that is manufactured to look organic. That is a straightforward misrepresentation of the market to the people trading in it, and in several of the markets we work in it is also illegal.
The version that works is the one that is written down: a published rule, disclosed participation, and a stated point at which it stops. Participants are generally fine with a market maker. They are not fine with discovering there was one.
When to give up on the second side
If the scarce side will not come for a free, hand-delivered, heavily subsidised version, the problem is not the mechanism. It is that they do not have the problem you think they have. That is a finding, and it is cheaper in month one than in year two.