A cap table the next round can take
Early equity feels free. There is no valuation worth arguing about, no investor to object, and plenty of reasons to be generous — the adviser who made an introduction, the friend who built the first version, the person who put in the first money when nobody else would.
Each of those decisions is defensible on its own. The sum of them is a document that an investor reads eighteen months later, and either can or cannot work with.
What makes a cap table unfundable
- Founders holding too little. If the people doing the work will own a trivial share after the next two rounds, the incentive that the whole investment depends on has already gone.
- Too many small holders. Every one of them is a signature, a consent and a potential hold-out at exactly the moment speed matters.
- Equity granted without vesting. Somebody who left in month four still owning what they were given in month one is a permanent, visible problem.
- No option pool. It gets created at the round instead, and it dilutes the founders rather than the incoming investor, which is rarely what anybody expected.
- Terms nobody remembers agreeing to. A convertible with an unusual cap, a side letter, a promise in an email.
The principle worth holding to
Whoever is running the company day to day should hold enough of it to still care at the next round. Everything else is negotiable.
That is not generosity to founders, it is self-interest for everybody on the table. The alternative — a founder who has worked out that the next round leaves them with nothing meaningful — ends the same way every time, and it ends worst for whoever holds the most.
The boring prevention
Vesting on everything, including the founders. An option pool sized before the raise rather than during it. Advisers on a schedule and a small number rather than a grant and a handshake. One document that is actually current, that somebody can produce within an hour of being asked.
None of it is clever. All of it is the difference between a round that takes six weeks and a round that takes six months of cleaning up first — assuming there is still six months of runway in which to do the cleaning.