Designing an event contract
A prediction market is a contract with a price attached. Almost everything that determines whether it works is decided in the contract, before anybody has built a screen to trade it on.
The wording is the product
Every event contract is an argument waiting to happen, and the wording is what settles the argument. "Will the shipment arrive in March?" is not a contract. Arrive where — the port, the warehouse, the customer? Arrive meaning physically present, or cleared, or signed for? March in which timezone? If it arrives damaged and is sent back, did it arrive?
Every one of those is a dispute that will occur, at the worst possible moment, with money on it. A contract that has not answered them has only deferred the answer to the point where somebody is motivated to answer it dishonestly.
Write the contract as though the person reading it is looking for a way to win on a technicality. Somebody will be.
The settlement source is the trust
A contract settles against something. That something has to be published, timely, hard to influence by anyone holding a position, and still going to exist when the contract matures.
- Published — if settlement depends on a private number, every participant is trusting whoever holds it.
- Timely — a source that updates quarterly cannot settle a weekly contract, no matter how authoritative it is.
- Hard to influence — if a large enough position could move the source itself, the contract is an incentive to do exactly that.
- Durable — indices get discontinued, agencies stop publishing, websites change their methodology without telling anybody.
When no source satisfies all four, the honest answer is that the contract cannot be written yet, not that it can be written with a committee as a fallback. Committees are how disputes become reputational events.
Somebody has to be wrong first
The third hard part is that a new market has no other side. The first person to arrive with a view finds nobody to take it, and leaves.
This is solvable, and the solution is unglamorous: somebody quotes both sides continuously, at a published rule, until there is enough natural flow that they can stop. That somebody takes real risk and will lose money doing it, which is why it has to be planned and funded rather than hoped for. A marketplace launched without it is a product that works perfectly and has nothing happening on it.
What a good contract looks like when you are done
You can hand it to somebody who was not in the room, ask them what happens in four awkward edge cases, and get the same four answers you would have given. If you cannot, the contract is not finished — and no amount of design on the trading screen will finish it.